Witherell Auctions
Live Auction

Luxury Asset Auction 10/29/2026

Thu, Oct 29, 2026 07:00PM EDT
  2026-10-29 19:00:00 2026-10-29 19:00:00 America/New_York Witherell Auctions Witherell Auctions : Luxury Asset Auction 10/29/2026 https://bid.witherell.com/auctions/witherells/luxury-asset-auction-10-29-2026-23593
Witherell's Live Luxury Asset Auction, October 29, 2026, from the Sutter Club, Sacramento. 363 lots: Warhol's $9, a Peale portrait, a Stone Declaration of Independence, Rolex, gold, fine jewelry, California baskets and more.
Witherell Auctions Brian@witherell.com
Lot 1

Rosalie S. Asher Archive of Caryl Chessman, America’s Most Famous Death Row Case, with Original Manuscripts, 1948–1963

Estimate: $1,000 - $2,500
Starting Bid
$500

Bid Increments

Price Bid Increment
$0 $50
$1,000 $100
$2,000 $250
$5,000 $500
$10,000 $1,000
$20,000 $2,500
$50,000 $5,000
$100,000 $10,000

An extensive and previously unpublished archive relating to Caryl Chessman (1921–1960), the most famous condemned prisoner in America during the 1950s and the central figure in one of the most widely publicized capital punishment cases in American history. Preserved by Sacramento attorney Rosalie S. Asher, a member of Chessman’s legal team, the approximately 2.5-linear-foot archive contains original literary manuscripts, legal briefs, correspondence, attorney working files, handwritten notebooks, research files, photographs, press material, and records documenting Chessman’s twelve years on San Quentin’s Death Row.

 

Convicted in 1948 as the notorious “Red Light Bandit,” Chessman received two death sentences under California’s kidnapping statute despite never being convicted of murder. His case became an international controversy, raising enduring questions about capital punishment, due process, and the limits of the criminal justice system. While pursuing his own appeals from Death Row, he became the first condemned prisoner to achieve worldwide literary success, publishing bestselling books before his execution in California’s gas chamber on May 2, 1960.

 

The archive preserves original working manuscripts for several of Chessman’s books, including a 263-page manuscript of The Kid Was a Killer; a three-volume carbon copy of Cell 2455, Death Row, later adapted into the Columbia Pictures feature film; and a three-volume carbon copy of Trial by Ordeal, including a cover boldly inscribed, “PROPERTY OF CARYL CHESSMAN #66565.” Also included are an edited manuscript of Duel with Death, drafts of My Client and I, and additional unpublished literary material.

 

The legal archive is equally significant, containing Chessman’s California Supreme Court appellate briefs prepared in propria persona, extensive material relating to the famous transcript controversy, attorney Rosalie Asher’s correspondence with San Quentin officials—including a signed 1959 letter transmitting The Kid Was a Killer manuscript for Chessman’s revision—contemporaneous notebooks, legislative hearing transcripts, radio and television scripts, research papers, photographs, and extensive documentation of the international clemency campaign.

 

Taken together, the archive chronicles not only the life of one of America’s most famous condemned prisoners, but also the intersection of crime, punishment, constitutional law, publishing, journalism, and the modern debate over capital punishment. Preserved substantially intact through Rosalie Asher’s family, it represents an exceptional primary-source archive documenting one of the most consequential criminal cases in twentieth-century American legal history.

 

Dimensions: Approximately 2.5 linear feet comprising multiple binders, manuscripts, legal files, correspondence, notebooks, photographs, and research material.


Pickup & Shipping: Free Sacramento pickup. Shipping via FedEx for $225 + 1.5% insurance (unless waived in writing).

Condition

Archive substantially intact with expected handling wear from active legal and editorial use, including annotations, editorial revisions, folds, toning, and filing marks throughout.

Available payment options

  • Visa
  • Mastercard
  • Amex
  • Diners
  • Discover
  • JCB
  • Union Pay

Shipping is only in continental U.S. and information regarding shipping price is provided within the description of each lot. For international and larger items that we cannot ship in house, please take a look at our shipping contacts.

Archive of Rosalie S. Asher, attorney for Caryl Chessman; retained by Asher and descended directly through her family to the present owner.